ZHANG Le-qin, RONG Hui-fang, CAO Xian-he. Comparing Two Methods of Forest Ecosystem Value Evaluation[J]. Bulletin of Soiland Water Conservation, 2011, 30(1): 169-174.
ZHANG Le-qin, RONG Hui-fang, CAO Xian-he. Comparing Two Methods of Forest Ecosystem Value Evaluation[J]. Bulletin of Soiland Water Conservation, 2011, 30(1): 169-174.DOI:
Currently a satisfying evaluation method has not been developed for the forest ecosystem evaluation yet.Based on the Costanza's method
XIE Gao-di introduced the equivalent weight factor method.In 2008
the Institute of Forest Eco-environment and Protection
Chinese Academy of Forestry promulgated the evaluation criterion of forest ecosystem(LY/T1721-2008).Taking the riverhead forest ecosystem of Qiupu River in Chizhou City
Anhui Province as an example
the two methods were applied to calculate the service value of the forest ecosystem as approximate-ly1.13×108Yuan and 4.94×108Yuan
respectively
in 2007.This large disagreement between two numbers could be attributed to the background behind which the methods were created
different concepts
index types and included parameters.Equivalent weight factor method was created based on conditional values
reflecting objectively the people's willingness to pay(WTP).However
it maybe not theoretically precise.LY/T1721-2008assessment method emphasizes more on theoretical application and is therefore more precise and accurate.However
its results may deviate considerably from the people's willingness to pay.